[PHP-DEV] [DISCUSSION] ext/intl: single-value skeleton formatter (GH-24165)

Hi,

GH-24165 asks for unit formatting in intl (e.g. “5 km/h”, “5 kilometers per hour”). NumberFormatter can’t do it as it sits on the legacy ICU API, and switching it to icu::number would break patterns, attributes and RBNF styles.

Since 8.6 it is doable with IntlNumberRangeFormatter by passing the same value twice, but that’s a hack.

I would like to add a single-value counterpart, IntlNumberFormatter, built from a skeleton:

echo IntlNumberFormatter::createFromSkeleton(
‘measure-unit/speed-kilometer-per-hour unit-width-full-name’, ‘fr’)->format(5);

It would cover units and the rest of what skeletons support, and it would only be available with a recent enough ICU.

Cheers.

Hi

On 2026-10-06 20:39, David CARLIER wrote:

I would like to add a single-value counterpart, IntlNumberFormatter, built
from a skeleton:

echo IntlNumberFormatter::createFromSkeleton(
    'measure-unit/speed-kilometer-per-hour unit-width-full-name',
'fr')->format(5);

It would cover units and the rest of what skeletons support, and it would
only be available with a recent enough ICU.

It's unfortunate that we would then have both `NumberFormatter` and `IntlNumberFormatter`, but getting something on the non-legacy API and with a proper `Intl` prefix would be a good thing. I'm thus in favor. As future scope we should probably deprecate `NumberFormatter` then.

Best regards
Tim Düsterhus